“This is not simply theft”: legal expert advising European bishops warns about church desecrations

In an exclusive interview with Press Crux, José Luis Bazán, a doctor of law and legal adviser to European bishops, explains how attacks on churches are investigated, when they may constitute hate crimes, and the responsibilities of public authorities.

EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW | CHURCH IN EUROPE |

Ana Paula Morales (Poli)

11/17/20268 min read

Photo caption: José Luis Bazán, doctor of law and legal adviser to the Commission of the Bishops’ Conferences of the European Union (COMECE), discusses church desecrations in Spain and the legal protection of religious freedom in an exclusive interview with Press Crux. Image digitally edited by Press Crux to include the European Union flag.

The theft of tabernacles, the disappearance of consecrated hosts and damage to Spanish churches have once again raised a question that goes beyond building security: how does the law protect the sacred character of what has been desecrated?

In Galicia, several churches suffered thefts and desecrations between August and October. These incidents were followed by the theft of a tabernacle containing around 30 consecrated hosts from the parish of Our Lady of the Assumption in Parla (Madrid), reported on October 22 by the Diocese of Getafe.

The concern extends beyond the monetary value of stolen objects. For Catholics, the Eucharist is central to their faith, and its desecration is a wound felt by the entire community.

In an earlier Press Crux interview, Bishop Fernando García Cadiñanos of Mondoñedo-Ferrol discussed the consequences of these incidents for Galician parishes.

To explore their legal dimension, Press Crux interviewed José Luis Bazán, a doctor of law, in writing. He explains the differences between theft, desecration and hate crimes; the obligations of Spanish authorities; and the avenues available through European institutions.

The full interview follows, preserving the sequence and substance of the questions and answers supplied by the interviewee.

Full interview | Questions and answers

1. Distinguishing the acts and their motives. In light of the thefts, damage and desecrations reported at churches in Galicia, what elements make it possible to distinguish legally between a property offense, an act of desecration and a crime motivated by religious discrimination? What signs should authorities investigate before attributing or ruling out that last motive?

These are three distinct types of criminal offense. Under Spain’s current Criminal Code, the demolition or serious alteration of buildings specially protected for their historic, artistic, cultural or monumental significance is punishable by six months to three years in prison and a fine calculated over 12 to 24 months (Article 321).

Acts of desecration committed “in a church, place intended for worship or during religious ceremonies” that offend legally protected religious feelings are different: the penalty is six months to one year in prison or a fine calculated over 12 to 24 months (Article 524).

Damage to churches, such as intimidating graffiti or slogans painted on their walls, falls under the general offense of criminal damage, which carries a lighter penalty. But if it can be inferred that the perpetrator intended not only to damage property but also to instill fear and intimidate members of a religious community, it could be treated as a threat against that community (Article 170).

Regarding religious discrimination, in Spain it is a crime to foster, promote or incite, directly or indirectly, hatred, hostility, discrimination or violence against a religious group, part of such a group or an individual. This carries one to four years in prison and a fine calculated over six to 12 months (Article 510.1(a)).

It is also an offense to harm people’s dignity through acts that humiliate, disparage or discredit a religious group (Article 510.2(a)), punishable by six months to two years in prison and a fine calculated over six to 12 months.

Discriminatory motivation may also be an aggravating factor in another offense (Article 22(4)), in addition to the crime of incitement to discrimination. Several offenses can occur in a single act: for example, forcing open a church tabernacle to take the consecrated hosts constitutes theft and desecration; if the church was also targeted because of hostility to Catholics, the aggravating factor may apply.

Because intention exists within an individual’s mind, authorities investigate motives by examining external evidence.

Spain’s law-enforcement protocol for so-called “hate crimes” lists what are known as bias indicators. They include the timing of the incident around important liturgical dates (such as Holy Week or a local patron saint’s feast); messages and symbols, whether physical or on social media; graffiti left by the perpetrator; repetition, including previous hate acts against the same or other churches; the perpetrator’s profile (past conduct, social circle, publications), clothing or appearance; connections to groups hostile to the religious community or religion; and the apparently gratuitous nature of the act.

As we can see, the available legal instruments permit the prosecution of offenders, provided there is the will and the necessary resources. It is also true, however, that identifying the perpetrator can sometimes be difficult, for instance in rural churches or hospital chapels where no one is permanently present to look after the premises.

2. Protection under Spanish law. When a tabernacle is desecrated or consecrated hosts are scattered, even if the economic value of what is stolen is negligible, what response does Spain’s Criminal Code allow? In your experience, what are the main obstacles to ensuring investigations and damage assessments reflect the religious dimension of such acts?

It is clear that economic value is not decisive in an act of desecration or damage to religious property, whether movable or immovable. The sacred character of an object cannot be measured in money because it is linked to a spiritual reality that transcends material calculation.

It is one thing to take account of material damage — for example, the cost of repairing a door forced open to enter a church — and quite another for protection to end there, without considering the religious nature of the damaged object. Sometimes material loss may be tiny — for example, the destruction of a consecrated host, whose material value is almost insignificant — while the moral harm is enormous.

Robbery committed in a building open to the public, such as a church, is punishable by two to five years in prison (Article 241.1). Theft of property of artistic, historical or cultural value carries one to three years in prison (Article 235.1). Damage to such property is punishable by six months to three years in prison or a fine calculated over 12 to 24 months (Article 323.1).

Scattering consecrated hosts is the clearest and most painful example of desecration under Article 524. If the prior theft and a hate-related aggravating factor are added, criminal-law protection against such conduct appears sufficient.

However, when economic value is low but the offense or moral harm arising from the religious nature of the property is high, it is essential to make this distinction clear and explicit in the initial statement. This is not merely robbery, theft or damage to property: the religious value and moral harm must be emphasized. Courts sometimes choose not to apply the offense of desecration because they rule out, or do not find, an intention to offend religious feelings.

Something similar happens with crimes requiring the intention to humiliate or incite discrimination on religious grounds. Although that difficulty may be genuine in certain cases, it can also become a back door for avoiding controversial decisions.

I would add that there is sometimes a lack of understanding of the nature and importance of the religious dimension of objects and of their significance to people. Secularization has led to growing religious ignorance, with the result that even public authorities and law-enforcement officers may see these incidents as simple theft or damage, without giving due weight to their impact on the affected individual or community.

Finally, such acts are clearly underreported. Hundreds, if not thousands, occur in Spain every year, and most are never reported, whether because of bureaucratic difficulties, the perception that they will not be investigated or punished, or, in some cases, an interpretation of the Christian principle of forgiveness that I believe is poorly founded.

3. The responsibility of public authorities. In light of Article 9 of the European Convention on Human Rights, what duties of prevention and protection does the state have when a community reports threats or repeated attacks on its church? Under what circumstances might an inadequate official response engage the state’s responsibility?

Article 9 of the Convention not only requires the state to refrain from interfering with individual or collective religious freedom. It also imposes positive obligations, including ensuring that believers can exercise that freedom peacefully, even in the face of attacks by private individuals.

The European Court of Human Rights, which interprets and applies the Convention, made this clear in Gldani v. Georgia (2007), condemning the state for failing to prevent violence against a religious group. In Karaahmed v. Bulgaria (2015), it found a failure to adequately protect worshippers praying in a mosque from a hostile demonstration.

Accordingly, when a religious community has suffered previous attacks or reports threats, authorities must assess the risk and respond by adopting reasonable preventive measures (such as patrols or information about protective measures), and, where appropriate, investigate the attacks, including their potential religious motive (Milanović v. Serbia, 2010).

The state bears responsibility when it is aware of a risk and fails to take the measures required.

Two points are important. First, the state cannot provide less protection to one religious community than to another; absent an objective and proportionate justification, that would constitute discrimination prohibited by Article 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Second, the state’s positive obligation is to take measures to prevent attacks, not to guarantee a particular result.

4. European remedies and their limits. If a parish or diocese believes it has not received effective protection in Spain, what avenues are available before the European Court of Human Rights, and what requirements must be met? What distinct roles can European Union institutions and the OSCE play, and what outcomes can be expected from each?

The European Court of Human Rights is the end of the road, not the beginning. All domestic remedies, ordinary or extraordinary, must first be exhausted. In Spain, this normally includes an amparo appeal before the Constitutional Court. The applicant must also be the victim of the alleged rights violation (a parish or diocese with legal personality could bring a claim), and the matter must be of sufficient seriousness or significance.

In any event, the Court’s impact is limited: it declares a violation if one has occurred and, where appropriate, awards compensation to the victim. Depending on the case, this may also lead to legislative change.

The European Union can finance security for places of worship, analyze data and trends, bring public attention to the problem, assess compliance with EU legislation — for example, concerning efforts to combat hate crime — and act as a source of political pressure.

The OSCE’s possibilities are more limited because it is an organization based on political commitments. Nevertheless, its Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights performs important work by publishing hate-crime data. In July 2025, it published a practical guide on anti-Christian hate crimes, a useful document for understanding and addressing this reality in Europe, particularly from the perspective of public authorities.

5. From reporting to effective protection. For a small parish that has just suffered an attack, what practical steps would you recommend to preserve evidence, file a complaint and document a possible anti-religious motive? Do you know of European practices of cooperation between authorities and religious communities that can protect churches while keeping them open to worshippers?

The parish should formally report the incident to the authorities (including the hate-crime prosecutor’s office) and leave the scene untouched until the police or Civil Guard arrive. It is important not to contaminate the scene and to preserve any potential evidence. Photographing or filming the area or damaged objects — graffiti, items scattered on the floor and so forth — is advisable. If there are security cameras nearby, the recordings should be requested before they are deleted.

An inventory should be made of what was stolen or destroyed, describing the affected items. More generally, it is advisable to maintain an inventory with photographs of objects whose economic or other value warrants it. If an anti-religious motive is suspected (see the bias indicators mentioned earlier), the complaint should expressly state this, with a request that it be recorded in the police report.

Because repetition can indicate bias, it is important to record and report previous incidents such as threats, graffiti or social-media messages suggesting a hate motive. Police officers cannot be assumed to understand the sacramental significance of a tabernacle or consecrated hosts, so that significance should be emphasized. Identifying possible witnesses who can help clarify the circumstances of the crime is equally important.

Informing news media and religious-freedom observatories can also help bring the offense to public attention.

Original: https://presscrux.org/no-es-un-simple-robo-experto-juridico-de-los-obispos-europeos-advierte-sobre-las-profanaciones-de-iglesias


News

Catholic analysis of the Church, politics, and culture.

Articles

Opinions

apmorales@presscrux.org

© 2026 Press Crux. All Rights Reserved.